Scarlett Johansson's non-MCU movies have received high ratings on IMDb. "We Bought A Zoo" (2011) is a heartwarming family movie where Johansson plays a sweet character. In "Vicky Cristina Barcelona" (2008), she portrays a neurotic part in a film about sex and love. "Ghost World" (2001) explores the end of puberty and conformity, with Johansson giving a dreary performance as a confused teenager. "Chef" (2014) showcases Johansson's influence despite her small role. In "The Man Who Wasn't There" (2001), she plays a young pianist in a vintage noir film. "Match Point" (2005) is a psychological thriller where Johansson's character faces desire and nostalgia.

In "Lost In Translation" (2003), Johansson plays a recent graduate trapped in a loveless marriage. "Marriage Story" (2019) showcases Johansson's portrayal of a character going through a divorce. In "Jojo Rabbit" (2019), Johansson delivers a challenging yet optimistic performance. Finally, in the highly rated "The Prestige" (2006), Johansson plays a supporting role as a magician's assistant.